AI emails impact brand loyalty: majority of consumers show resistance
Consumers express concerns about the authenticity of AI-generated emails, posing risks to brand reputation, especially in healthcare and finance.
A recent study by Exclaimer, an email signature management platform, reveals a growing resistance to AI-generated emails, with 80% of consumers likely to switch brands that rely heavily on AI for communication. The study surveyed 1,000 individuals across various age groups, from Gen Z to Baby Boomers, to understand how AI impacts brand perception. According to the research, 55% of respondents view AI-driven communications negatively, with 79% stating they might switch brands if AI is the primary tool used in brand communications.
One of the key findings is that 41% of consumers feel AI-driven emails diminish the authenticity of brand messaging, leading to less trust and transparency. Nearly one in five respondents noted that even subtle AI use in emails can be detected and has a negative impact on brand communication quality. This disconnect makes 27% of respondents feel less connected to brands using AI-generated emails, which could lead to a significant customer churn.
The study also highlighted generational differences in responses to AI-generated emails. For each generation, the likelihood of switching brands is as follows:
- Gen Z - 85%
- Millennials - 80%
- Gen X - 77%
- Baby Boomers - 75%
Overall, 88% of consumers indicated they would ignore suspected AI-generated marketing emails, with 51% being less likely to recommend brands that rely on such tools. This suggests that companies need to carefully assess the use of AI in their email communications to avoid damaging their brand reputation and losing customer loyalty.
Patrecia Meliana
While many consumers express concerns about AI-generated emails, there are still areas where AI can provide value in marketing campaigns. One significant advantage is personalization. About 32% of consumers recognize AI’s ability to deliver tailored discounts and offers, making it an effective tool for enhancing customer engagement when used strategically.
AI can also optimize email marketing by analyzing data to predict customer behavior, helping brands send the right message at the right time. By focusing on personalization and timing, AI allows businesses to create more relevant and impactful communications, improving open rates and customer loyalty. When used as a supportive tool rather than the primary mode of communication, AI has the potential to boost campaign effectiveness without losing the human touch.
This balance between automation and personal connection is key, especially in sectors like retail and technology, where AI-generated content is generally more accepted. For businesses, leveraging AI to enhance personalization while maintaining authenticity can help drive positive results in their marketing efforts.
Carol Howley, CMO at Exclaimer, emphasized the need for brands to strike the right balance in AI usage. "Our research shows that while AI has a place in marketing, consumers still want a human connection. Brands need to ensure that AI enhances, rather than detracts from, the customer experience by keeping communications subtle and human-like." For sectors like healthcare and finance, Howley noted the importance of maintaining a personal touch to avoid alienating consumers.
Free AI email generating tools to try
This free AI tool offers pre-built email templates that businesses can customize for their email campaigns. It’s known for generating concise, creative content that sounds human-like, helping companies maintain a personal touch while leveraging AI for efficiency.
Rytr is another free tool that uses AI to create personalized emails for marketing and customer service. With a user-friendly interface, it allows businesses to easily generate emails that feel tailored to individual customer preferences, boosting engagement.
WriteSonic offers a free plan that helps companies craft various types of emails, including cold outreach, follow-ups, and newsletters. Its AI-driven templates can be customized, making email creation faster while keeping the content engaging and relevant.
Paid AI email generating tools available
As a premium AI-powered content generator, Jasper AI helps businesses create highly personalized emails by using advanced natural language processing. It’s especially valuable for larger companies looking for scalable, human-like email content to improve customer relationships.
Known for its language refinement tools, Grammarly Business also provides AI-driven email generation for professional settings. Its focus on tone adjustments ensures that communications remain appropriate and personable, making it ideal for industries where professionalism is key, such as healthcare and finance.
This email marketing platform goes beyond standard automation by using AI to optimize email content for engagement. With its AI-driven insights, businesses can predict the best times to send emails and tailor messages to specific customer segments, enhancing the effectiveness of their campaigns.
ContentGrow is a managed talent network for brands and publishers to work with high-quality freelance writers and journalists worldwide. Sign up to get started or book a discovery call to learn more.
