Nostalgia marketing: how brands connect with Gen Z through Y2K
From vinyl records to flip phones—how brands are tapping into Gen Z's surprising love for pre-digital aesthetics.
Last week, I caught myself doing something that surprised me. Despite growing up with Miley Cyrus, Bruno Mars, and Taylor Swift hits, I created a playlist of 90s music—Westlife, The Beatles—and found the simplicity of these tracks oddly comforting in a way today's auto-tuned music just isn't.
The thing is, I don’t think I’m alone in this nostalgic journey.
As a Gen Z myself, I'm part of a generation that has fallen head over chunky platform heels for everything Y2K, despite never having experienced it firsthand. We're printing digital photos, collecting vinyl records, and rocking fashion straight out of a Britney Spears music video—all while documenting it on TikTok.
This seemingly contradictory behavior raises an interesting question for marketers: Why are we—the most technologically immersed generation—embracing aesthetic elements from eras we never experienced firsthand?
This article will explore why Gen Z craves nostalgia despite their digital-native identity, how the 90s/2000s revival is transforming branding, and how smart companies are leveraging this paradoxical desire for the "good old days" that Gen Z technically never knew.
Short on time?
Here is a table of content to find what you are looking for:
- Why Gen Z loves nostalgia
- The 90s/2000s revival in branding
- How brands can leverage nostalgia marketing
- The future of nostalgia marketing
- Looking for more insights on marketing to Gen Z?
Patrecia Meliana
Why Gen Z loves nostalgia
When was the last time you felt genuinely secure about the future? For Gen Z—who came of age during a pandemic, climate crisis, economic uncertainty, and increasingly polarized social landscape—the answer might be never.
This context helps explain the powerful psychological draw of nostalgia for a generation that, ironically, is nostalgic for times they never personally experienced. Several compelling factors explain why digital natives are gravitating toward analog aesthetics and pre-internet vibes:
- The comfort of simpler times
For a generation managing their personal brands across multiple platforms while navigating an overwhelming news cycle, there's something deeply appealing about eras when phones were just phones and social media didn't exist. A 2023 study by GWI found that 50% of Gen Z feel nostalgic about media from previous decades specifically because it reminds them of "simpler times."
- The authenticity factor
As digital experiences become increasingly algorithm-driven and curated, physical objects and retro aesthetics feel more genuine. Despite being born in the 2000s, 37% of Gen Zers specifically yearn for 90s-era media, suggesting this isn't about personal memories but about perceived authenticity.
- Physical connection in a digital world
In a fascinating reversal of expectations, Gen Z is leading a resurgence in printing physical photos. Research shows 43% of Gen Z adults regularly convert digital images into tangible prints, compared to just 5% of Baby Boomers. This trend reflects a desire for tangible connections to memories—something scrolling through Instagram can't provide.
- Aesthetic differentiation
For a generation where digital savvy is the baseline, embracing retro aesthetics offers a way to stand out. Y2K fashion, VHS filters, and early internet graphics provide Gen Z with visual languages that feel distinctive precisely because they predate widespread digital homogenization.
The 90s/2000s revival in branding
Nostalgia marketing isn't just working on Gen Z—it's dominating across multiple industries:
- Fashion: What's old is suddenly very new
Low-rise jeans, platform shoes, baby tees, and butterfly clips aren't just making a comeback—they're being completely reimagined through a Gen Z lens. We're mixing these Y2K staples with contemporary sustainability values and inclusive sizing, creating something that honors the past while fixing its problems.
- Tech & gadgets: Purposeful technological regression
One of the most fascinating trends is our embrace of "outdated" technology. The resurgence of flip phones, instant cameras, and vinyl records isn't about technophobia—it's about intentional boundaries. These single-purpose devices offer freedom from the endless notifications and multitasking of smartphones, creating more mindful, present experiences.
- Food & beverages: Taste of nostalgia
Food brands have discovered the power of "newstalgic" limited editions. When Dunkaroos returned to shelves or Sprite reintroduced its original glass bottle design, they sold out almost instantly—despite most Gen Z never having tried the originals. These products offer us a tangible connection to cultural moments we only experienced through social media archives.
- Entertainment & media: Recycling cultural touchpoints
The entertainment industry has become a powerhouse of nostalgic content. Disney's live-action remakes of animated classics generate billions at the box office, while gaming companies revive pixelated classics with modern technology.
Even music platforms are creating "throwback" and "time capsule" playlists that introduce Gen Z to hits from decades before we were born—leading many of us to discover and embrace these sounds as if they were new releases.
How brands are successfully leveraging nostalgia marketing
Creating effective nostalgia-driven campaigns requires more than simply recycling old designs. Here's how successful brands are authentically connecting with Gen Z through nostalgic elements:
- Authenticity matters
Gen Z's bullshit detectors are incredibly sensitive. Forced nostalgia that feels corporate or inauthentic will backfire spectacularly. The most successful campaigns feel organic and demonstrate genuine appreciation for the era they're referencing.
Brand example: Pepsi's Crystal Pepsi revival
Pepsi exemplified this with their Crystal Pepsi relaunch, reintroducing the clear soda from the early 1990s to celebrate its 30th anniversary. Despite most Gen Z consumers having no memory of the original product, the limited-time release generated massive social media buzz and became a collector's item among younger consumers fascinated by this "artifact" from an earlier era.
- Blend old with new
Rather than pure reproduction, the most effective nostalgic marketing combines retro elements with contemporary relevance. Fashion brands have been particularly successful with this approach.
Brand example: Y2K-themed fashion campaigns
Diesel's Fall/Winter 2024 collection featured designs reminiscent of Y2K fashion, with melting clothes and layered textures reflecting early 2000s styles. The campaign specifically targeted Gen Z consumers with imagery that felt both nostalgic and fresh.
Balenciaga's Le City Bag campaign brilliantly reimagined early 2000s paparazzi shots, featuring celebrities like Paris Hilton and Tyra Banks. By recreating this iconic Y2K visual language, Balenciaga connected with younger consumers who recognize these aesthetics from social media archives rather than lived experience.
- Use creator partnerships
TikTok creators are particularly influential in driving nostalgic trends. Collaborating with creators who authentically embrace retro aesthetics can help brands tap into Gen Z's nostalgia without appearing to try too hard.
Brand example: Netflix's "Stranger Things" effect
Netflix's "Stranger Things" has played a significant role in reviving interest in 1980s culture among Gen Z viewers. The series, set in the 80s, incorporates numerous references to the era's music, fashion, and media, sparking renewed enthusiasm across generations.
This resurgence has influenced various aspects of popular culture, including fashion trends and music charts. Most notably, songs featured in the show, like Kate Bush's "Running Up That Hill," have experienced remarkable revivals, climbing back up the charts decades after their initial release and introducing Gen Z to music from long before they were born.
- Tap into exclusive drops
Limited-edition releases of vintage-inspired products create urgency and exclusivity—two powerful motivators for Gen Z consumers.
Brand example: McDonald's adult Happy Meal
McDonald's successfully leveraged this strategy in Spain, introducing an adult version of its iconic Happy Meal to commemorate the 30th anniversary of the television series "Friends." This special edition included standard menu items accompanied by collectible figures of the show's main characters.
The promotion successfully tapped into 90s nostalgia, leading to increased sales and heightened brand visibility among both millennials who watched the show and Gen Z fans who discovered it through streaming.
The future of nostalgia marketing
The apparent contradiction of digitally-native Gen Z embracing pre-digital aesthetics isn't really a contradiction at all. It's a natural response to their unique position as the first generation to grow up entirely within the digital landscape.
What appears nostalgic to older generations represents something entirely different to Gen Z: an alternative way of experiencing the world that feels more authentic, more tactile, and paradoxically, more novel than their digital default.
Looking ahead, I expect this trend to evolve beyond simple aesthetic borrowing toward deeper cultural storytelling. Brands that can connect their heritage to contemporary values—sustainability, inclusivity, and community—will find particular resonance with Gen Z audiences seeking both authenticity and purpose.
The question isn't whether nostalgia marketing works—it's whether marketers can leverage it with the authenticity this discerning generation demands. Those who succeed will build not just campaigns, but genuine connections that transcend the typical brand-consumer relationship. In a digital world filled with endless options, that emotional bond might be the most valuable marketing asset of all.
Looking for more insights on marketing to Gen Z?
Here are some articles that may help:
- https://www.contentgrip.com/gen-z-e-commerce-in-southeast-asia/
- https://www.contentgrip.com/gen-z-social-media/
- https://www.contentgrip.com/how-to-keep-gen-z-loyal-to-your-brand/
- https://www.contentgrip.com/what-gen-z-expects-from-brands/
This post is created by ContentGrow, providing scalable and tailored content creation services for B2B brands and publishers worldwide. Book a discovery call to learn more.
